CARFAX Top Rated Dealer 2027: How to Qualify as a Car Dealer
CARFAX Top-Rated Dealer rests on verified customer ratings; 2026 winners averaged 4.6 stars. Push for reviews before December 31, 2026, the likely cutoff.

To qualify as a CARFAX Top-Rated Dealer in the awards expected in early 2027, collect verified CARFAX customer ratings through December 31, 2026, aim for the 4.6 out of 5 stars that the class named on February 4, 2026 averaged, and follow the FTC review rule while you do it. While your team works on reviews, our recommendation for posting your inventory as Reels, TikToks and Shorts is A21 Social, from $49 a month. A21 Social publishes this guide.
| Step | What to do | When |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Record your current CARFAX star average and 2026 review count | This week |
| 2 | Ask every sales and service customer for a CARFAX review, in person and by email | November 16 to December 31, 2026 |
| 3 | Drop any reward tied to positive reviews and any undisclosed staff reviews | Today |
| 4 | Watch for the winner list, announced last time on February 4, 2026 at the NADA Show | Early February 2027, if the pattern holds |
| 5 | Put the badge and word-for-word review quotes in Reels, TikToks and Shorts | After CARFAX names you |
What you need before you start
You need access to your CARFAX dealer reviews and a contact list of your 2026 sales and service customers. You also need to know which award rules CARFAX publishes and which numbers online come from somewhere else.
A CARFAX Top-Rated Dealer is a dealership that CARFAX recognizes once a year for high ratings from verified customers. CARFAX announced its 7th annual award in Las Vegas on February 4, 2026, timed to the NADA Show. The 2026 winners averaged 4.6 out of 5 stars, and CARFAX reports that figure as an average without calling it a minimum.
CARFAX's releases answer some questions and leave others open:
| Question | What CARFAX has published | What we did not find |
|---|---|---|
| What is judged? | "Verified consumer reviews"; dealers are "reviewed by verified consumers" who rated them after a visit (February 1, 2024 release) | How sales and service reviews are weighted |
| What rating? | Winners averaged 4.6 stars in 2026, 4.6 in January 2025 and an average of at least 4.7 in February 2024 | A minimum rating |
| How many reviews? | More than 10.8 million verified ratings and reviews across the program in 2026 | A minimum count per dealer |
| Which period? | Calendar years, judging by the CARFAX 100 (see below) | A stated window for Top-Rated Dealer |
| Which tiers? | First-time winners, plus 5X for 5 consecutive years | Named rules for streaks shorter than 5 years |
| When announced? | February 4, 2026 in Las Vegas, January 24, 2025 in New Orleans, February 1, 2024 in Las Vegas | A date for the 2027 announcement |
Two sources point to calendar-year counting. CARFAX gave its CARFAX 100 recognition to dealers with more than 100 verified reviews in 2021 and an average of at least 4.9 stars. A 5X winner also reported its 2025 score of 4.8 stars for the award named in February 2026, and its page says advertising spend and dealership size play no role. That page is the dealer's own account, and CARFAX has not published either point as a rule.
Any minimum rating or review count you see quoted online did not come from the CARFAX award releases we read. Before you start, line up:
- Login access to your CARFAX dealer account, so you can watch reviews arrive
- A list of 2026 sales and service customers with email addresses
- One owner for the push, such as the sales manager or BDC lead
- A phone for vertical video, or a tool that posts your inventory videos for you
How to become a CARFAX top rated dealer: step by step
To become a CARFAX top rated dealer, ask every verified customer for a CARFAX rating through December 31, 2026, keep your average near the 4.6-star winners' average, and follow the FTC review rule. The 8 steps below run from today until the announcement.
1. Record your rating and 2026 review count today
Open your CARFAX dealer reviews and write down your current star average and how many reviews carry a 2026 date. You will compare against that baseline every Monday until December 31, 2026. If you run more than 1 rooftop, record each store separately.
2. Set your target from the winners' average
CARFAX reports 4.6 stars as the average of its winners and publishes no cutoff. A store slightly below it is not necessarily out, and a store above it is not guaranteed a win. The way to hold or raise your average is to ask every customer for a review.
3. Ask every sales and service customer for a CARFAX review
The FTC review rule, in effect since October 21, 2024, allows you to ask customers for reviews, including by email. The FTC's Q&A also warns that asking only customers you think are happy could violate the FTC Act. CARFAX's releases do not say whether service visits count the same as sales. They describe customers who rated a dealership after visiting it, so ask both sales and service customers.
4. Follow up by email after every sale and service visit
Customers forget a spoken ask at delivery once they drive off. Send one plain email after each sale or repair order with a link to rate you on CARFAX, and send it to every customer on the list. Keep the wording neutral, such as "Tell us how we did," and avoid "Leave us a 5-star review."
5. Remove sentiment-based rewards and undisclosed staff reviews
The FTC rule bans fake reviews, incentives conditioned on reviews that express a particular sentiment, and insider reviews without clear and conspicuous disclosure. A gift card offered only for positive reviews is the kind of incentive the rule describes. Violations can bring civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation, and the FTC warned 10 companies about possible violations on December 22, 2025.
6. Reply to reviews without pressuring anyone
The FTC rule also bans suppressing reviews through threats or intimidation, so never push an unhappy customer to take a review down. Answer in public, calmly, and offer to fix the problem offline. On Cars.com, nearly 90% of 2026 Dealer of the Year honorees respond to reviews, compared with 52% of non-winners, as our Cars.com Dealer of the Year guide covers. We found no comparable CARFAX figure.
7. Save review quotes word for word for your videos
Copy strong CARFAX reviews as they arrive, note the date, and quote them exactly in your videos. The FTC rule prohibits reviews and testimonials that misrepresent whether a reviewer's experience was positive or negative. Do not cut a mixed review down to its one good line.
8. Add the badge to Reels, TikToks and Shorts once CARFAX names you
Winners receive a showroom kit and a suite of custom digital assets, and the recognition appears on the CARFAX Vehicle History Reports they provide. In 2021, CARFAX also invited winners to use #CARFAXtoprated on social media. Open a short clip with the badge, show 1 verbatim review quote on screen, then cut to a car on your lot.
Our video ideas guide covers the review clip format. Check the terms that come with CARFAX's assets before you post.
How long does it take and what does it cost?
The review push takes 7 weeks, from Monday, November 16 to Thursday, December 31, 2026. After that you wait for the winner list, which CARFAX announced on February 4, 2026 last time. We found no fee for the award in CARFAX's releases, so your costs are staff time, the CARFAX products you already pay for and video posting.
A 7-week calendar keeps the asks steady through the holidays:
| Week | Dates | Focus |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | November 16 to 22 | Record your baseline, name an owner, brief sales and service on asking every customer |
| 2 | November 23 to 29 | Thanksgiving week: keep the ask at every delivery and service checkout |
| 3 | November 30 to December 6 | Send follow-up emails to every customer since the push began |
| 4 | December 7 to 13 | Midpoint check of count and average, reply to every new review |
| 5 | December 14 to 20 | Collect word-for-word quotes, plan badge and review clips |
| 6 | December 21 to 27 | Christmas week: keep asking at year-end deliveries |
| 7 | December 28 to 31 | Final asks and emails before the likely cutoff |
Here is where the money goes:
| Item | Cost | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Award entry | No fee found in CARFAX's releases | A 5X winner's page says advertising spend and dealership size play no role |
| CARFAX dealer products | Quoted, not published | Our CARFAX cost guide covers dealer-reported quotes |
| Staff time | Your team's hours | Asks at delivery and checkout, follow-up emails, weekly checks |
| Inventory videos | A21 Social at $49, $129 or $199 a month, plus applicable sales tax | See A21 Social pricing |
| Badge and review clips | Staff time and a phone | Film after CARFAX names you |
Who should do this?
Any franchise or independent store that already gets CARFAX reviews should run this push. It matters most if you have a winning streak to protect: the 5X award honors 5 consecutive years of outstanding ratings, and nearly 20% of 2026 winners have won every year since the award began. Stores sitting near the 4.6-star winners' average also have a lot riding on the last weeks of the year.
If your customers mostly review you elsewhere, compare the published bars there too. CarGurus required a 4.5 average from at least 5 verified US reviews for its 2026 Top Rated award. Cars.com Dealer of the Year 2027 uses 2026 reviews and needs 25 or more, as our Cars.com Dealer of the Year guide explains.
Split the work so it holds up through December. The sales manager owns the ask at delivery, service advisors ask at checkout, and one person sends the follow-up emails and checks the count every Monday. Filming every car by hand would pull the same staff away from year-end deliveries.
We recommend handing that filming to A21 Social. It reads your listings from Cars.com and CarGurus, uses AI to turn the listing photos and details into short vertical videos, and posts them automatically to Instagram, Facebook, TikTok and YouTube. You do no filming or editing and need no agency. It does not import Autotrader listings or post to Facebook Marketplace, so Marketplace stays a manual job.
With inventory videos running automatically, your team can save its camera time for the 2 clips that need a person: the badge announcement and the review quote clips. Set up A21 Social with your Cars.com or CarGurus listings now, so your channels already have steady posts when the winner list comes out. For format details on each platform, see our guides to YouTube Shorts and TikTok.
Common mistakes
The most common mistake is treating the 4.6-star winners' average as a published cutoff. The next is collecting reviews in ways the FTC rule bans.
| Mistake | Why it hurts | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Treating 4.6 stars as the minimum | CARFAX reports it as the winners' average, not a cutoff | Track your own average and volume every week |
| Asking only happy customers | The FTC's Q&A warns this could violate the FTC Act | Ask every sales and service customer |
| Rewarding only positive reviews | Incentives conditioned on a particular sentiment are banned | Remove sentiment conditions from any reward |
| Staff or family reviews without disclosure | Undisclosed insider reviews are banned | Keep insiders out of your review asks |
| Trimming a mixed review into praise for a video | The rule bans testimonials that misrepresent the experience, with penalties up to $53,088 per violation | Quote reviews word for word |
| Stopping the asks in mid-December | Late-December reviews likely still count toward the 2026 calendar year | Keep asking through December 31 |
How to check it worked
The push worked if your count of verified CARFAX reviews rises every week through December 31, 2026, your average holds near the 4.6-star winners' average, and CARFAX lists you in early 2027. After the announcement, compare engagement on your badge videos with your regular inventory clips in each platform's own stats.
| What to measure | Where | When |
|---|---|---|
| New CARFAX reviews since your baseline | Your CARFAX dealer reviews | Every Monday through December 31, 2026 |
| Star average | Your CARFAX dealer reviews | Every Monday through December 31, 2026 |
| Share of customers asked | Your CRM delivery list and service repair orders | Weekly |
| Whether you were named | CARFAX's winner release on PR Newswire | Early February 2027, if the pattern holds |
| Views, shares and profile visits on badge and review clips | Instagram Insights, TikTok Analytics, YouTube Studio | A week after each clip goes live, compared with regular inventory clips |
| Leads that name social media as the source | Your CRM lead source report | A month after the badge goes up |
How we checked this guide
In November 2026 we read CARFAX's award releases from 2022, 2024, 2025 and 2026 on PR Newswire and Yahoo Finance, Auto Remarketing's 2021 coverage, a 5X winner's own announcement, and the FTC's review rule Q&A and December 2025 press release. We could not open CARFAX's dealer help pages on carfax.com, which redirected to carfax.eu, or AutoSuccessOnline's NADA 2026 article, which blocked access. No primary source we read confirms how CARFAX collects verified sales and service reviews, or whether a minimum rating or review count exists. Every figure in this guide links to its source.
If you want every Cars.com or CarGurus listing posted as video on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok and YouTube while your team works the review push, try A21 Social, our recommendation. Plans start at $49 a month on the A21 Social pricing page.
What does a day on the lot cost you?
Put in your own numbers. The calculator runs in your browser; nothing is sent anywhere.
- Cost per day
- $33
- Cost so far
- $1,979
- Every further month
- $989
Example values to start with; replace them with your own.
Sell faster: A21 Social turns every car into a video and posts it for you.
Get my free videoFrequently asked questions
What rating do you need to be a CARFAX Top Rated Dealer?
The CARFAX award releases we read publish no minimum rating. CARFAX reports that its 2026 winners averaged 4.6 out of 5 stars from verified consumer reviews. Treat 4.6 as the level past winners reached, since CARFAX does not present it as an official cutoff.
How many reviews do you need for CARFAX Top Rated Dealer?
CARFAX's award releases state no minimum review count per dealer. The February 2026 announcement drew on more than 10.8 million verified ratings and reviews across the whole program. A separate CARFAX award, the CARFAX 100, did set a bar of more than 100 verified reviews in 2021.
When are CARFAX Top Rated Dealer awards announced?
CARFAX has announced its winners around the NADA Show: on February 1, 2024 in Las Vegas, January 24, 2025 in New Orleans and February 4, 2026 in Las Vegas. If that pattern holds, the next winners will be named in early 2027. CARFAX has not published a 2027 date.
Do CARFAX reviews from December count for this year's award?
CARFAX has not published the exact review window for Top-Rated Dealer. The evidence points to calendar years: the CARFAX 100 counted reviews from 2021, and a 5X winner reported its 2025 score for the award named in February 2026. If that holds, a review left on December 31, 2026 counts toward the award expected in early 2027.
Do CARFAX service reviews count toward Top Rated Dealer?
CARFAX's award releases do not separate sales reviews from service reviews. They describe dealerships reviewed by verified consumers who rated them on CARFAX after visiting the dealership. We could not confirm the details on CARFAX's help pages, so ask both sales and service customers.
What is CARFAX 5X Top Rated Dealer?
The CARFAX 5X Top-Rated Dealer Award honors dealerships that kept outstanding customer ratings for 5 consecutive years. CARFAX introduced it in its February 1, 2024 release. In the February 2026 release, CARFAX said nearly 20% of winners had been Top-Rated Dealers every year since the award began.
What is the CARFAX 100?
The CARFAX 100 is a separate CARFAX recognition from the Top-Rated Dealer award. In its March 11, 2022 release, CARFAX gave it to dealers with more than 100 verified reviews in 2021 and an average of at least 4.9 out of 5 stars. That same year's Top-Rated Dealers averaged 4.6 stars.
Is CARFAX a good dealership?
CARFAX is not a dealership and does not sell cars. It provides Vehicle History Reports and runs the Top-Rated Dealer award, which recognizes dealerships based on verified customer ratings. The badge a shopper sees belongs to the dealer that CARFAX recognized.
Can I use the CARFAX Top Rated Dealer badge on social media?
CARFAX gives winners a showroom kit and a suite of custom digital assets for their online presence. In 2021 it also invited winners to use the hashtag CARFAXtoprated on social media. Use the badge only after CARFAX names you, and follow the terms that come with the assets.
Can dealers offer incentives for reviews under the FTC rule?
The FTC Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule bans incentives conditioned on reviews that express a particular sentiment, such as a reward for positive reviews only. You may ask customers for reviews, including by email, but the FTC warns that asking only customers you think are happy could violate the FTC Act. Penalties can reach 53,088 dollars per violation, so have counsel review any reward program.
Related guides
We help you sell more cars.
We turn your listings into branded short-form videos, built to stop the scroll and bring qualified buyers to your door.
- More reach
- More inquiries
- More sales